College of Education research summaries

Analyzing Student Self-and-Peer Feedback to Improve and Enhance Teamwork

A two-semester analysis of 5,534 CATME comments in an engineering capstone

Huang, W., Wynkoop, R., Exter, M., & Berry, F. (2026). Analyzing student self-and-peer feedback to improve and enhance teamwork. TechTrends. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11528-026-01204-2

Purdue College of Education Cobrand

Purpose and Scope

  • Examines what students emphasize in self-and-peer feedback
  • How closely comments align with CATME’s five teamwork dimensions
  • Which valued qualities fall outside the rubric
  • How these patterns change over time

Research Design

175
Capstone Students Four engineering programs
35
Project Teams Three to eight members
6
Evaluation gates Across two semesters
5,534
Written comments Self and peer feedback

Comments

1,024 self-feedback

4,410 peer feedback

Repeated-measures longitudinal analysis

Five CATME Dimensions

  1. Contributing to the team’s work
  2. Interacting with teammates
  3. Keeping the team on track
  4. Expecting quality
  5. Having related knowledge, skills, and abilities

Feedback Aligned Narrowly with CATME

Self-Feedback

Many comments missed the CATME criteria

33-46%
Feedback not aligned with any CATME criteria
52-60%
Team Contribution Most common dimension mentioned
0.6-5.1%
Expecting Quality Least common dimension mentioned

Only three out of 1,024 entries covered all five criteria.


Peer Feedback

Most comments covered one criteria

~1
Dimension on average
60-72%
Team Contribution Most common dimension mentioned
6-18%
Expecting Quality Least common dimension mentioned

Only one peer comment covered all five criteria.

Designing Technology-Enabled Feedback

Connect formal criteria with what students value.

  1. Teach all five dimensions with examples and calibration.
  2. Use stage-specific prompts across project milestones.
  3. Consider leadership and creativity in the feedback framework.
  4. Use comment summaries for timely team coaching.